Value Fund · head to head · AMFI NAVs
ICICI Prudential Value Fund vs Tata Value Fund: SIP returns compared
Same ₹10,000 monthly SIP, same dates, Direct plans: over the last 5 years ICICI Prudential Value Fund is worth ₹7.55 L (XIRR 9.4%) and Tata Value Fund ₹7.72 L (XIRR 10.4%) — Tata Value Fund ahead by ₹17,495. Across every 5-year SIP since Jan 2013, ICICI Prudential Value Fund finished ahead in 67 of 106 and Tata Value Fund in 39.
Historical simulation on actual NAVs — not a forecast and not investment advice. Disclaimer
ICICI Prudential Value Fund: invested — over — instalments; valued at NAV of —:
| Year | Invested | ICICI Prudential Value Fund value | XIRR to date |
|---|
₹10,000 a month in each: what it became
Each row is a monthly SIP ending today (1 Oct 2026), Direct plans. Post-tax assumes everything is redeemed today with no other capital gains this year.
| SIP period | Invested | ICICI Prudential Value Fund | XIRR | Tata Value Fund | XIRR | Post-tax (both) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 year | ₹1,20,000 | ₹1.11 L | -15.3% | ₹1.16 L | -6.7% | ₹1.11 L / ₹1.16 L |
| 3 years | ₹3,60,000 | ₹3.60 L | -0.0% | ₹3.68 L | 1.6% | ₹3.60 L / ₹3.68 L |
| 5 years | ₹6,00,000 | ₹7.55 L | 9.4% | ₹7.72 L | 10.4% | ₹7.51 L / ₹7.66 L |
| 10 years | ₹12,00,000 | ₹26.15 L | 15.1% | ₹24.13 L | 13.6% | ₹24.57 L / ₹22.80 L |
Every 5-year SIP, head to head
We started the same SIP in both funds in every month both have NAVs for — 106 SIPs, the first starting Jan 2013. ICICI Prudential Value Fund finished ahead in 63% of them; the median gap was 1.7 percentage points a year in ICICI Prudential Value Fund's favour.
Downside on the same dates: ICICI Prudential Value Fund's worst 5-year SIP returned -8.4% a year (started Apr 2015) and 2 of 106 lost money; Tata Value Fund's worst returned -5.2% (started Apr 2015) and 2 lost money.
XIRR of every 5-year monthly SIP by the month it started. Gap = ICICI Prudential Value Fund minus Tata Value Fund, percentage points a year.
| Window | SIPs compared | Ahead (ICICI / Tata) | Median gap | Worst gap | Best gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3-year SIPs | 130 | 57% / 43% | +1.2 pp | -13.4 ppstarted Oct 2014 | +11.3 ppstarted Mar 2019 |
| 5-year SIPs | 106 | 63% / 37% | +1.7 pp | -7.0 ppstarted May 2013 | +7.0 ppstarted Feb 2018 |
Against an index fund, and the cost of the Regular plan
- ICICI Prudential Value Fund beat a plain Nifty 500 index fund in 94% of 49 rolling 3-year SIPs (median gap +6.9 pp a year) — ICICI Prudential Value Fund vs Nifty 500 index fund.
- ICICI Prudential Value Fund: the Regular plan of the same 10-year SIP ended ₹89,356 below Direct.
- Tata Value Fund beat a plain Nifty 500 index fund in 94% of 49 rolling 3-year SIPs (median gap +3.2 pp a year) — Tata Value Fund vs Nifty 500 index fund.
- Tata Value Fund: the Regular plan of the same 10-year SIP ended ₹1,50,284 below Direct.
Questions
Which has given better SIP returns, ICICI Prudential Value Fund or Tata Value Fund?
Over the last 5 years a ₹10,000 monthly SIP (Direct plans) is worth ₹7.55 L in ICICI Prudential Value Fund (XIRR 9.4%) and ₹7.72 L in Tata Value Fund (XIRR 10.4%). Past returns don't tell you which will do better next.
Has ICICI Prudential Value Fund beaten Tata Value Fund consistently?
In 63% of 106 rolling 5-year SIPs started on the same dates (from Jan 2013), ICICI Prudential Value Fund ended ahead of Tata Value Fund (Direct plans). The median difference was +1.7 percentage points a year.
Where does this data come from?
Official daily NAVs published by AMFI. SIP instalments fall on the first business day of each month; both funds are compared on identical dates. Updated monthly.
Comparison on official AMFI NAVs, SIP on the first business day of each month, identical dates for both funds. It shows what happened, not which fund to buy — past performance does not indicate future returns. sipcalculatorhub.com is not a SEBI-registered investment adviser. Methodology.
More comparisons
- ICICI Prudential Value Fund vs Aditya Birla Sun Life Value Fund
- ICICI Prudential Value Fund vs Axis Value Fund
- ICICI Prudential Value Fund vs Bandhan Value Fund
- ICICI Prudential Value Fund vs HDFC Value Fund
- ICICI Prudential Value Fund vs Nippon India Value Fund
- ICICI Prudential Value Fund vs UTI Value Fund
- Tata Value Fund vs Aditya Birla Sun Life Value Fund
- Tata Value Fund vs Axis Value Fund
- Tata Value Fund vs Bandhan Value Fund
- Tata Value Fund vs HDFC Value Fund
- Tata Value Fund vs Nippon India Value Fund
- Tata Value Fund vs UTI Value Fund